Evolution of Types of Democracy and the Threat of Populism for Transitive States: a Media Aspect

Serhiy Danylenko, Iryna Rodina

Abstract


Drawing from the examples of newly formed and former democracies, the article examines the directions which the transformation of this political concept has taken in context of the expansion of the public sphere and changes in how the democratic process is implemented. Attention is drawn to how the transition of the forefront of political life from traditional centers of its “distribution”- governments, parliaments, and municipal authorities, to the “fatherland” of the public sphere and media of varying quality has become one of the reasons for the accelerated proliferation of politics of the populist variety. The rise of media in Ukraine, where it falls under complete ownership of centers of oligarchy, provides grounds for mentioning a special type of “oligarchic democracy”, which serendipitously exploits the opportunities offered by populism. At the same time, the examples of democratic crises in other nations have become widespread enough, so that they encourage casting doubt on crucial democratic processes, including elections: electoral democracy has formally taken place, although it hasn’t fulfilled its essential function of including the citizenry in making key social decisions. Researchers assert that media is not the only source that breathes life into populist politics as a means to seize power. This carries the threat of destroying the very institutions through which the democratic form of government is realized. Transitional democracies are also subjected to the erosion of populism through problems with asserting the supremacy of law and difficulties with establishing liberal market economics, which should have been synchronized with their political transformation. Authors refer to the fact, that populism is a problem shared by governments with diverse histories of democratic life. Behind democracy always lurks the threat of false self-rule, which can lead to the rise of new authoritarian regimes under the guise of populist conservative declarations and national protectionism. Russia could become an example of this, after its wholly democratic process of voting on amendments to its national constitution, which is expected during 2020. Controversy in equal or greater measure has also surrounded the future of Great Britain after Brexit.


Keywords


democratic crises, political populism, “Trumpism”, media, Poland, Hungary, USA, Ukraine

References


Discours du Président de la République à la conférence des des ambassadeurs et des ambassadrices de 2019, https://www.elysee.fr/emmanuel-macron/2019/08/27/discours-du-president-de-la-republique-a-la-conference-des-ambassadeurs-1

Donald Trump. Speeches. Tweets. Policy, https://factba.se/trump

Europe Wrestles With Hungary’s Populist Challenge,

https://www.cfr.org/in-brief/europe-wrestles-hungarys-populist-challenge

Exit polls, https://edition.cnn.com/election/2016/results/exit-polls

Finchelstein, F., Urbinati, N. On Populism and Democracy, Brill, 2018, p. 15-37.

Hendriks, F., Vital Democracy: A Theory of Democracy in Action, Oxford: Oxford UP, 2010, 256 p.

Kenny, Paul D. «The Enemy of the People»: Populists and Press Freedom, https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/1065912918824038.

Level of media control in Hungary is “unprecedented in an EU member state, https://rsf.org/en/news/level-media-control-hungary-unprecedented-eu-member-state

Poland’s State Media Is Government’s Biggest Booster Before Election, https://www.nytimes.com/2019/10/11/world/europe/poland-election-state-television-tvp.htm

Polish opposition warns refugees could spread infectious diseases, https://www.reuters.com/article/us-europe-migrants-poland/polish-opposition-warns-refugees-could-spread-infectious-diseases-idUSKCN0S918B20151015

Reporters Without Borders: Poland, https://rsf.org/en/poland

Rochester, A., The Populist Movement in the United States, Published by International Publishers, New York, 1943.

Sharon, A., Populism and Democracy: The Challenge for Deliberative Democracy, Eur JPhilos. 2019, 27: p. 359–376.

The Great Recession has influenced populist movements today, say Stanford scholars, https://news.stanford.edu/2018/12/26/explaining-surge-populist-politics-movements-today/

Ukrainian ambassador rejects Polish premier's 'million refugees' claim, https://uk.reuters.com/article/uk-europe-migrants-poland-ukraine-idUKKCN0UY2BN

Verhofstadt, G., Is COVID-19 Killing Democracy?, Project Syndicate, https://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/covid19-democracy-violations-by-guy-verhofstadt?barrier=accesspaylog

Zelenko G., External Factors in Political Transition in Eastern Europe, „Wschód Europy”, vol. 4, № 2, 2018, p. 85 – 97.

Hans-Adam II., Derzhava u tret”omu tysyacholitti, DIPA, Kyyiv, 2018, s. 86.

Kauch, K., «Nasha model” demokratyy ne daet nam shansov na uchastye v polytyke», https://www.colta.ru/articles/society/22161-kolin-krauch-nasha-model-demokratii-ne-daet-nam-shansov-dlya-uchastiya-v-politike

Kukhyanydze A., Demokratyya y polytycheskaya transformatsyya v Gruzyy (1991 – 2018), „Wschód Europy”, vol. 4, № 2, 2018, p. 137 – 155.

Kyn Dzh., Demokratyya y dekadans medya, per. s. anhl. D. Kralechkyna; pod nauch. red. A. Smyrnova; NYU «VShЭ», Moskva, Yzd. dom VShЭ, 2015, s. 104 – 105.

Muff, Sh., Postdemokratyya y postpolytyka, http://gefter.ru/archive/10510

Pocheptsov, H., Te, shcho vidbulos” na vyborakh, - rezul”tat konsensusu oliharkhiv, https://glavcom.ua/interviews/georgiy-pochepcov-te-shcho-vidbulos-na-viborah-rezultat-konsensusu-oligarhiv-655305.html

Postroenye demokratyy: Ukrayna y Yaponyya. Pomoshch” Ukrayne v dele demokratyzatsyy so storony Yaponyy v 2015 godu, pod red. R. Syratory, K. Khasymoto, M. Rozumnoho, Kyev; «Fenyks», NYSY, 2016, 640 s.

Pro stan rozvytku hromadyans”koho suspil”stva v Ukrayini: analit. dopovid”, [Yablons”kyy V. M., Balakiryeva O. M., Bondar T. V. ta in.]; za zah. red. O. A. Korniyevs”koho, Kyyiv, NISD, 2017, 56 s.

Samorukov M., Poka Bryussel” ne smotryt. Kak yzmenyt Pol”shu y Evropu novaya pobeda Kachynskoho, https://carnegie.ru/commentary/80061

Transformatsiyni protsesy u krayinakh Vyshehrads”koyi hrupy ta Ukrayini: porivnyal”nyy analiz, za red. prof. H.M. Perepelytsi, Kyyiv: Vydavnychyy dim «Stylos», 2013, 302 s.

Tuzhans”kyy D., Vartovi rezhymu Viktora Orbana, https://medialab.online/news/magyarorszag/

Zablots”kyy V., Populizm, [v:] Filosofs”kyy entsyklopedychnyy slovnyk, V. I. Shynkaruk (holova redkolehiyi) ta in.; L. V. Ozadovs”ka, N. P. Polishchuk (naukovi redaktory); I. O. Pokarzhevs”ka (khudozhnye oformlennya), Kyyiv: Abrys, 2002, 742 s.




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.17951/we.2020.6.2.59-78
Date of publication: 2020-12-28 21:24:16
Date of submission: 2020-12-23 09:15:36


Statistics


Total abstract view - 1670
Downloads (from 2020-06-17) - PDF (Русский) - 0

Indicators



Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Copyright (c) 2020

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.