What if the Truth does not Exist... or the Role of Values in Historiography (in Defense of Historical Truth)

Marek Woźniak

Abstract


In the article, I try to answer questions about the role/functions of values in historical writing, about their place in the narrative, and I wonder whether historiography free from (historical) truth is at all possible. I assume, referring primarily to the sociology of knowledge and tools offered by the constructivist model of cognition, that the position regarding truth/value in historical research is realised in three (at least) attitudes, namely conservative, liberal and pragmatic. The superstitions present in each of them determine the attitude to truth/values and their functions in cognitive processes. The observations presented in the article show that the truth/truths/values turn out to be essentially rhetorical arguments used in disputes between competing visions/images of the past/the world. Their functions come down to strengthening/creating the authority of the Historian and, consequently, to conducting a (proper) historical policy.


Keywords


truth, values, historiography, historical research, research process, the ideal/model of historical science

Full Text:

PDF (Język Polski)

References


Pomorski J., Historiografia jako autorefleksja kultury poznającej, w: Świat historii, red. W. Wrzosek, Poznań 1998.

Pomorski J., Historyk i metodologia, Lublin 1991.

Pomorski J., Społeczna funkcja historii – analiza kontekstów znaczeniowych pojęcia, w: Społeczna funkcja historii a współczesność, red. Z. Mańkowski, J. Pomorski, Lublin 1985.

Stobiecki R., Historia pod nadzorem: spory o nowy model historii w Polsce (II połowa lat czterdziestych – początek lat pięćdziesiątych), Łódź 1993.

Valéry P., Regards sur le monde actuel, Paris 1931.

Woźniak M., Od prawdy historycznej do sensu dziejów. Wartości a obraz przeszłości, w: Aksjologiczne aspekty dyskursu humanistycznego, Chełm 2012.

Zamorski K., Dziwna rzeczywistość, Kraków 2008.




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.17951/rh.2018.46.351-363
Date of publication: 2019-04-25 10:00:44
Date of submission: 2018-01-05 09:26:44


Statistics


Total abstract view - 1805
Downloads (from 2020-06-17) - PDF (Język Polski) - 676

Indicators



Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Copyright (c) 2019 Marek Woźniak

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.