Unreliability of Goldman’s Reliabilizm in the Context of Dispute Concerning Justification

Cezary Mordka

Abstract


In the paper, I present one of the most important contemporary attempts of defeating fundamental problems concerning justification in the context of doxastic assumption. Goldman rejects thesis that we cannot take account of anything except insofar we have believes about it, assumption accepted by foundations and coherence theories. Instead of faulty (above mentioned) views, Goldman indicates reliable cognitive processes as perception, memory, and reasoning. In my paper, I present the whole gamut of arguments against Goldman’s theory but as decisive I consider faults on the ground of reliability concerning perception.


Keywords


epistemology; coherence theories; foundations theories; justification; perception; reliabilism; truth

Full Text:

PDF (Język Polski)

References


Audi R., The Structure of Justification, Cambridge 1993.

Ayer A., Problem poznania, przeł. E. Konig-Chwedeńczuk, Warszawa 1965.

BonJour L., The Structure of Empirical Knowledge, Cambridge 1985.

Chisholm R.M., Teoria poznania, przeł. R. Ziemińska, Lublin 1994.

Foley R., What’s wrong with Reliabilism?, “Monist” 1985, No. 68.

Ginet C., Contra Reliabilism, „Monsit” 1985, No. 68.

Goldman A.I., Discrimination and Perceptual Knowledge, [w:] Knowledge and Justification, ed. E. Sosa, Vol. 1, Dartmouth 1994.

Goldman A.I., Epistemology and Cognition, Cambridge 1986.

Goldman A.I., Knowledge and Justification, ed. E. Sosa, Vol. 1, Darthmouth 1994.

Goldman A.I., What is Justified Belief?, [w:] Empirical Knowledge, ed. P. Moser, Rowman–Allanheld 1986.

Lehrer K., Theory of Knowledge, Boulder 1990.

Moser P.K., Mulder D.H., Trout J.D., The Theory of Knowledge, New York–Oxford 1998.

Pollock J.L., Cruz J., Contemporary Theories of Knowledge, Lanham 1999.

Szubka T., Analityczna teoria poznania, [w:] Studia metafilozoficzne. Dyscypliny i metody filozofii, red. A.B. Stępień, T. Szubka, Lublin 1993.

Windblad D.G., Scepticism and Naturalized Epistemology, “Philosophia” 1989, Vol. 19.

Ziemińska R., Eksternalizm we współczesnej epistemologii, Szczecin 2002.




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.17951/i.2017.42.2.89
Date of publication: 2018-06-13 09:03:27
Date of submission: 2018-02-21 11:49:42


Statistics


Total abstract view - 1348
Downloads (from 2020-06-17) - PDF (Język Polski) - 0

Indicators



Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Copyright (c) 2018 Cezary Mordka

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.